James:2:14-26
rwp@James:2:14 @{What doth it profit?} (\ti ophelos;\). Rhetorical question, almost of impatience. Old word from \ophell\, to increase, in N.T. only here, verse 16; strkjv@1Corinthians:15:32|. "\Ti ophelos\ was a common expression in the vivacious style of a moral diatribe" (Ropes). {If a man say} (\ean legi tis\). Condition of third class with \ean\ and the present active subjunctive of \leg\, "if one keep on saying." {He hath faith} (\pistin echein\). Infinitive in indirect assertion after \legi\. {But have not works} (\erga de m echi\). Third-class condition continued, "but keeps on not having (\m\ and present active subjunctive \echi\) works." It is the spurious claim to faith that James here condemns. {Can that faith save him?} (\m dunatai h pistis ssai auton;\). Negative answer expected (\m\). Effective aorist active infinitive \ssai\ (from \sz\). The article \h\ here is almost demonstrative in force as it is in origin, referring to the claim of faith without works just made.
rwp@James:2:15 @{If a brother or sister be naked} (\ean adelphos adelph gumnoi huparchsin\). Condition again of third class (supposable case) with \ean\ and present active subjunctive of \huparch\, to exist, in the plural though \\ (or) is used and not \kai\ (and). Hence \gumnoi\ is masculine plural in the predicate nominative. It does not here mean absolutely naked, but without sufficient clothing as in strkjv@Matthew:25:36ff.; strkjv@John:21:7; strkjv@Acts:19:16|. {In lack of daily food} (\leipomenoi ts ephmerou trophs\). Present passive participle of \leip\ and ablative case \trophs\ like \leipetai sophias\ (1:5|). The old adjective \ephmeros\ (\ho epi hmeran n\, that which is for a day) occurs here only in the N.T., though \ephmeria\ (daily routine) is found in strkjv@Luke:1:5,8|. This phrase occurs in Diodorus, but not in LXX.
rwp@James:2:16 @{And one of you say unto them} (\eipi de tis autois ex humn\). Third-class condition again continued from verse 15| with second aorist active subjunctive \eipi\. {Go in peace} (\hupagete en eirni\). Present active imperative of \hupag\. Common Jewish farewell (Judges:18:6; strkjv@1Samuel:1:17; strkjv@20:42; strkjv@2Samuel:15:9|). Used by Jesus (Mark:5:34; strkjv@Luke:7:50|). {Be ye warmed and filled} (\thermainesthe kai chortazesthe\). Present imperative either middle (direct) or passive. We have \thermainomai\ as a direct middle in strkjv@John:18:18| (were warming themselves) and that makes good sense here: "Warm yourselves." \Chortaz\ was originally used for pasturing cattle, but came to be used of men also as here. "Feed yourselves" (if middle, as is likely). Instead of warm clothes and satisfying food they get only empty words to look out for themselves. {And yet ye give not} (\m dte de\). Third-class condition with \de\ (and yet) and \m\ and the second aorist active subjunctive of \didmi\, to give, cold deeds with warm words. {The things needful to the body} (\ta epitdeia tou smatos\). "The necessities of the body" (the necessaries of life). Old adjective from adverb \epitdes\ (enough), only here in N.T. {What doth it profit?} (\ti ophelos;\). As in verse 14| and here the conclusion (apodosis) of the long condition begun in verse 15|.
rwp@James:2:17 @{If it have not works} (\ean m echi erga\). Another condition of the third class with \ean\ and \m\ and the present active subjunctive of \ech\, "if it keep on not having works." {In itself} (\kath' heautn\). In and of itself (according to itself), inwardly and outwardly dead (\nekra\). Same idiom in strkjv@Acts:28:16; strkjv@Romans:14:22|. It is a dead faith.
rwp@James:2:18 @{Yea, a man will say} (\all' erei tis\). Future active of \eipon\. But \all'\ here is almost certainly adversative (But some one will say), not confirmatory. James introduces an imaginary objector who speaks one sentence: "Thou hast faith and I have works" (\Su pistin echeis kag erga ech\). Then James answers this objector. The objector can be regarded as asking a short question: "Hast thou faith?" In that case James replies: "I have works also." {Show me thy faith apart from thy works} (\deixon moi tn pistin sou chris tn ergn\). This is the reply of James to the objector. First aorist active imperative of \deiknumi\, tense of urgency. The point lies in \chris\, which means not "without," but "apart from," as in strkjv@Hebrews:11:6| (with the ablative case), "the works that properly belong to it and should characterise it" (Hort). James challenges the objector to do this. {And I by my works will shew thee my faith} (\kag soi deix ek tn ergn mou tn pistin\). It is not faith _or_ works, but proof of real faith (live faith _vs_. dead faith). The mere profession of faith with no works or profession of faith shown to be alive by works. This is the alternative clearly stated. Note \pistin\ (faith) in both cases. James is not here discussing "works" (ceremonial works) as a means of salvation as Paul in strkjv@Galatians:3; strkjv@Romans:4|, but works as proof of faith.
rwp@James:2:19 @{Thou believest that God is one} (\su pisteueis hoti heis theos estin\). James goes on with his reply and takes up mere creed apart from works, belief that God exists (there is one God), a fundamental doctrine, but that is not belief or trust in God. It may be mere creed. {Thou doest well} (\kals poieis\). That is good as far as it goes, which is not far. {The demons also believe} (\kai ta daimonia pisteuousin\). They go that far (the same verb \pisteu\). They never doubt the fact of God's existence. {And shudder} (\kai phrissousin\). Present active indicative of \phriss\, old onomatopoetic verb to bristle up, to shudder, only here in N.T. Like Latin _horreo_ (horror, standing of the hair on end with terror). The demons do more than believe a fact. They shudder at it.
rwp@James:2:20 @{But wilt thou know?} (\theleis de gnnai?\). "But dost thou wish to know?" Ingressive aorist active infinitive of \ginosk\ (come to know). James here introduces a new argument like strkjv@Romans:13:3|. {O vain man} (\ anthrpe kene\). Goes on with the singular objector and demolishes him. For "empty" (deficient) Paul uses \aphrn\ (fool) in strkjv@1Corinthians:15:36| and just \anthrpe\ in strkjv@Romans:2:1; strkjv@9:20|. {Barren} (\arge\). See strkjv@2Peter:1:8| (not idle nor unfruitful) and strkjv@Matthew:12:36|, but Hort urges "inactive" as the idea here, like money with no interest and land with no crops.
rwp@James:2:21 @{Justified by works} (\ex ergn edikaith\). First aorist passive indicative of \dikaio\ (see Galatians and Romans for this verb, to declare righteous, to set right) in a question with \ouk\ expecting an affirmative answer. This is the phrase that is often held to be flatly opposed to Paul's statement in strkjv@Romans:4:1-5|, where Paul pointedly says that it was the faith of Abraham (Romans:4:9|) that was reckoned to Abraham for righteousness, not his works. But Paul is talking about the faith of Abraham before his circumcision (4:10|) as the basis of his being set right with God, which faith is symbolized in the circumcision. James makes plain his meaning also. {In that he offered up Isaac his son upon the altar} (\anenegkas Isaak ton huion autou epi to thusiastrion\). They use the same words, but they are talking of different acts. James points to the offering (\anenegkas\ second aorist--with first aorist ending--active participle of \anapher\) of Isaac on the altar (Genesis:22:16f.|) as _proof_ of the faith that Abraham already had. Paul discusses Abraham's faith as the basis of his justification, that and not his circumcision. There is no contradiction at all between James and Paul. Neither is answering the other. Paul may or may not have seen the Epistle of James, who stood by him loyally in the Conference in Jerusalem (Acts:15; strkjv@Galatians:2|).
rwp@James:2:22 @{Thou seest} (\blepeis\). Obvious enough with any eyes to see. This may be a question, seest thou? {Wrought with} (\sunrgei\). Imperfect active of \sunerge\, old verb for which see strkjv@Romans:8:28|. Followed by associative-instrumental case \ergois\. Faith cooperated with the deed of offering up Isaac. {Was made perfect} (\eteleith\). First aorist passive indicative of \teleio\, to carry to the end, to complete like love in strkjv@1John:4:18|. See strkjv@James:1:4| for \teleion ergon\.
rwp@James:2:23 @{Was fulfilled} (\eplrth\). First aorist passive indicative of \plro\, the usual verb for fulfilling Scripture. Songs:James quotes strkjv@Genesis:15:6| as proving his point in verse 21| that Abraham had works with his faith, the very same passage that Paul quotes in strkjv@Romans:4:3| to show that Abraham's faith preceded his circumcision and was the basis of his justification. And both James and Paul are right, each to illustrate a different point. {And he was called the friend of God} (\kai philos theou eklth\). First aorist passive indicative of \kalo\. Not a part of the Scripture quoted. Philo calls Abraham the friend of God and see _Jubilees_ strkjv@19:9; strkjv@30:20. The Arabs today speak of Abraham as God's friend. It was evidently a common description before James used it, as in strkjv@Isaiah:41:8; strkjv@2Chronicles:20:7|.
rwp@James:2:24 @{Ye see} (\horte\). Present indicative active of \hora\. Now he uses the plural again as in strkjv@2:14|. {Is justified} (\dikaioutai\). Present passive indicative of \dikaio\, here not "is made righteous," but "is shown to be righteous." James is discussing the proof of faith, not the initial act of being set right with God (Paul's idea in strkjv@Romans:4:1-10|). {And not only by faith} (\kai ouk ek pistes monon\). This phrase clears up the meaning of James. Faith (live faith) is what we must all have (2:18|), only it must shew itself also in deeds as Abraham's did.
rwp@James:2:25 @{Rahab the harlot} (\Raab h porn\). Her vicious life she left behind, but the name clung to her always. For our purposes the argument of James may seem stronger without the example of Rahab (Joshua:2:1-21; strkjv@6:17; 22-25; strkjv@Matthew:1:5; strkjv@Hebrews:11:31|). It is even said in Jewish Midrash that Rahab married Joshua and became an ancestor of Jeremiah and Ezekiel. {In that she received} (\hupodexamen\). First aorist middle participle of \hupodechomai\, to welcome. {The messengers} (\tous aggelous\). Original meaning of \aggelos\ (Matthew:11:10|). In strkjv@Hebrews:11:31| we have \kataskopous\ (spies, scouts). {Sent out} (\ekbalousa\). Second aorist active participle of \ekball\, to hurl out. {Another way} (\heteri hodi\). "By another way" (instrumental case), by a window instead of a door (Joshua:2:15f.|).
rwp@James:2:26 @{Apart from the spirit} (\chris pneumatos\). "Apart from breath" (the breath of life). It is not easy to tell when one is dead, but the absence of a sign of breath on a glass before the mouth and nose is proof of death. Startling picture of dead faith in our churches and church members with only a name to live (Revelation:3:2|).
![[pBiblx2]](/img/pbiblx2_logo3.png){kind=logo}