rwp - hotan

rwp@John:7:27 @{Howbeit} (\alla\). Clearly adversative here. {This man} (\touton\). Possibly contemptuous use of \houtos\ as may be true in 25,26|. {Whence he is} (\pothen estin\). The Galilean Jews knew the family of Jesus (6:42|), but they knew Jesus only as from Nazareth, not as born in Bethlehem (verse 42|). {When the Christ cometh} (\ho Christos hotan erchtai\). Prolepsis of \ho Christos\ and indefinite temporal clause with \hotan\ and the present middle subjunctive \erchtai\ rather than the more usual second aorist active \elthi\ as in verse 31|, a trifle more picturesque. This is a piece of popular theology. "Three things come wholly unexpected--Messiah, a godsend, and a scorpion" (_Sanhedrin_ 97a). The rulers knew the birthplace to be Bethlehem (7:42; strkjv@Matthew:2:5f.|), but some even expected the Messiah to drop suddenly from the skies as Satan proposed to Jesus to fall down from the pinnacle of the temple. The Jews generally expected a sudden emergence of the Messiah from concealment with an anointing by Elijah (_Apoc. of Bar_. XXIX. 3; 2Esdr. strkjv@7:28; strkjv@13:32; Justin Martyr, _Tryph_. 110).

rwp@John:7:31 @{When the Christ shall come} (\ho Christos hotan elthi\). Proleptic position of \ho Christos\ again as in 27|, but \elthi\ with \hotan\ rather than \erchtai\, calling more attention to the consummation (whenever he does come). {Will he do?} (\m poisei;\). Future active indicative of \poie\ with \m\ (negative answer expected). Jesus had won a large portion of the pilgrims (\ek tou ochlou polloi\) either before this day or during this controversy. The use of \episteusan\ (ingressive aorist active) looks as if many came to believe at this point. These pilgrims had watched closely the proceedings. {Than those which} (\hn\). One must supply the unexpressed antecedent \toutn\ in the ablative case after \pleiona\ (more). Then the neuter plural accusative relative \ha\ (referring to \smeia\ signs) is attracted to the ablative case of the pronominal antecedent \toutn\ (now dropped out). {Hath done} (\epoisen\). First aorist active indicative of \poie\, a timeless constative aorist summing up all the miracles of Jesus so far.

rwp@Revelation:8:1 @{And when he opened} (\kai hotan noixen\). Here modal \an\ is used with \hote\ (used about the opening of the preceding six seals), but \hotan\ is not here rendered more indefinite, as is sometimes true (Mark:3:11; strkjv@Revelation:4:9|), but here and possibly (can be repetition) in strkjv@Mark:11:19| it is a particular instance, not a general rule (Robertson, _Grammar_, p. 973). {There followed a silence} (\egeneto sig\). Second aorist middle of \ginomai\. "There came silence." Dramatic effect by this profound stillness with no elder or angel speaking, no chorus of praise nor cry of adoration, no thunder from the throne (Swete), but a temporary cessation in the revelations. See strkjv@10:4|. {About the space of half an hour} (\hs hmiron\). Late and rare word (\hmi\, half, \hra\, hour), here only in N.T. Accusative of extent of time.

CONCORD hotan