OT-LAW.filter - rwp Barabb:

rwp@Acts:21:36 @{Followed after} (\kolouthei\). Imperfect active of \akoluthe\, was following. Cheated of their purpose to lynch Paul, they were determined to have his blood. {Crying out} (\krazontes\). Construction according to sense, plural masculine participle agreeing with neuter singular substantive \plthos\ (Robertson, _Grammar_, p. 401). {Away with him} (\Aire auton\). The very words used by the mob to Pilate when they chose Barabbas in preference to Jesus (Luke:23:18|, \Aire touton\). He will hear it again from this same crowd (Acts:22:22|). It is the present imperative (\aire\) as in strkjv@Luke:23:18|, but some may have used the urgent aorist active imperative as also in the case of Jesus strkjv@John:19:15|, \ron, ron\ with \staurson\ added). Luke does not say that this mob demanded crucifixion for Paul. He was learning what it was to share the sufferings of Christ as the sullen roar of the mob's yells rolled on and on in his ears.

rwp@Luke:22:52 @{As against a robber?} (\hs epi listn;\). They were treating Jesus as if he were a bandit like Barabbas.

rwp@Luke:23:25 @{Whom they asked for} (\hon itounto\). Imperfect middle, for whom they had been asking for themselves. Luke repeats that Barabbas was in prison "for insurrection and murder." {To their will} (\ti thelmati autn\). This is mob law by the judge who surrenders his own power and justice to the clamour of the crowd.

rwp@Luke:23:33 @{The skull} (\to kranion\). Probably because it looked like a skull. See on ¯Matthew:27:33; strkjv@Mark:15:22|. {There they crucified him} (\ekei estaursan\). There between the two robbers and on the very cross on which Barabbas, the leader of the robber band, was to have been crucified. {One} (\hon men\), {the other} (\hon de\). Common idiom of contrast with this old demonstrative \hos\ and \men\ and \de\.

rwp@Mark:14:48 @{Against a robber} (\epi listn\). Highway robbers like Barabbas were common and were often regarded as heroes. Jesus will be crucified between two robbers in the very place that Barabbas would have occupied.

rwp@Mark:15:7 @{Bound with them that had made insurrection} (\meta tn stasiastn dedemenos\). A desperate criminal, leader in the insurrection, sedition (\en ti stasei\), or revolution against Rome, the very thing that the Jews up at Bethsaida Julias had wanted Jesus to lead (John:6:15|). Barabbas was the leader of these rioters and was bound with them. {Had committed murder} (\phonon pepoikeisan\). Past perfect indicative without augment. Murder usually goes with such rioters and the priests and people actually chose a murderer in preference to Jesus.

rwp@Mark:15:9 @{The King of the Jews} (\ton basilea tn Ioudain\). That phrase from this charge sharpened the contrast between Jesus and Barabbas which is bluntly put in strkjv@Matthew:27:17| "Barabbas or Jesus which is called Christ." See discussion there.

rwp@Mark:15:11 @{Stirred up} (\aneseisan\). {Shook up} like an earthquake (\seismos\). strkjv@Matthew:27:20| has a weaker word, "persuaded" (\epeisan\). Effective aorist indicative. The priests and scribes had amazing success. If one wonders why the crowd was fickle, he may recall that this was not yet the same people who followed him in triumphal entry and in the temple. That was the plan of Judas to get the thing over before those Galilean sympathizers waked up. "It was a case of regulars against an irregular, of priests against prophet" (Gould). "But Barabbas, as described by Mark, represented a popular passion, which was stronger than any sympathy they might have for so unworldly a character as Jesus--the passion for _political liberty_" (Bruce). "What unprincipled characters they were! They accuse Jesus to Pilate of political ambition, and they recommend Barabbas to the people for the same reason" (Bruce). The Sanhedrin would say to the people that Jesus had already abdicated his kingly claims while to Pilate they went on accusing him of treason to Caesar. {Rather} (_mllon_). Rather than Jesus. It was a gambler's choice.

rwp@Mark:15:12 @{Whom ye call the King of the Jews} (\hon legete ton basilea tn Ioudain\). Pilate rubs it in on the Jews (cf. verse 9|). The "then" (\oun\) means since you have chosen Barabbas instead of Jesus.

rwp@Matthew:26:55 @{As against a robber} (\hs epi listn\). As a robber, not as a thief, but a robber hiding from justice. He will be crucified between two robbers and on the very cross planned for their leader, Barabbas. They have come with no warrant for any crime, but with an armed force to seize Jesus as if a highway robber. Jesus reminds them that he used to sit (imperfect, \ekathezomn\) in the temple and teach. But he sees God's purpose in it all for the prophets had foretold his "cup." The desertion of Jesus by the disciples followed this rebuke of the effort of Peter. Jesus had surrendered. Songs:they fled.

rwp@Matthew:27:17 @{Barabbas or Jesus which is called Christ?} (\Barabbn Isoun ton legomenon Christon;\). Pilate was catching at straws or seeking any loophole to escape condemning a harmless lunatic or exponent of a superstitious cult such as he deemed Jesus to be, certainly in no political sense a rival of Caesar. The Jews interpreted "Christ" for Pilate to be a claim to be King of the Jews in opposition to Caesar, "a most unprincipled proceeding" (Bruce). Songs:he bethought him of the time-honoured custom at the passover of releasing to the people "a prisoner whom they wished" (\desmion hon thelon\). No parallel case has been found, but Josephus mentions the custom (_Ant_. xx. 9,3). Barabbas was for some reason a popular hero, a notable (\epismon\), if not notorious, prisoner, leader of an insurrection or revolution (Mark:15:7|) probably against Rome, and so guilty of the very crime that they tried to fasten on Jesus who only claimed to be king in the spiritual sense of the spiritual kingdom. Songs:Pilate unwittingly pitted against each other two prisoners who represented the antagonistic forces of all time. It is an elliptical structure in the question, "whom do you wish that I release?" (\tina thelete apolus;\), either two questions in one (asyndeton) or the ellipse of \hina\ before \apolus\. See the same idiom in verse 21|. But Pilate's question tested the Jews as well as himself. It tests all men today. Some manuscripts add the name Jesus to Barabbas and that makes it all the sharper. Jesus Barabbas or Jesus Christ?

rwp@Matthew:27:20 @{Persuaded} (\epeisan\). The chief priests (Sadducees) and elders (Pharisees) saw the peril of the situation and took no chances. While Pilate wavered in pressing the question, they used all their arts to get the people to "ask for themselves" (\aitsntai\, indirect middle ingressive aorist subjunctive) and to choose Barabbas and not Jesus.

rwp@Matthew:27:22 @{What then shall I do unto Jesus which is called Christ?} (\ti oun pois Isoun ton legomenon Christon;\). They had asked for Barabbas under the tutelage of the Sanhedrin, but Pilate pressed home the problem of Jesus with the dim hope that they might ask for Jesus also. But they had learned their lesson. Some of the very people who shouted "Hosannah" on the Sunday morning of the Triumphal Entry now shout {Let him be crucified} (\staurtht\). The tide has now turned against Jesus, the hero of Sunday, now the condemned criminal of Friday. Such is popular favour. But all the while Pilate is shirking his own fearful responsibility and trying to hide his own weakness and injustice behind popular clamour and prejudice.

rwp@Matthew:27:38 @{Robbers} (\listai\). Not thieves (\kleptai\) as in Authorized Version. See strkjv@Matthew:26:55|. These two robbers were probably members of the band of Barabbas on whose cross Jesus now hung.